During a recent conversation I said that the Anderson Faery/Feri lineage of witchcraft is helpful for trauma survivors because it is an embodied lineage with a focus on ecstatic experience – all things that steer us out of over intellectualizing and into body awareness – but only insofar as we work to heal our trauma, else it will retraumatize us. I’ve been pondering that statement ever since, because while I feel it to be true I have never upacked it. I’m going to try and do that a bit here.
What is trauma, and what does it mean to be retraumatized? We often think of trauma as tied to emotional, physical or sexual abuse, war, or natural disasters, but there are a whole range of life experiences that can be traumatizing, like surgery, the loss of a loved one, etc. Trauma happens when our nervous system is overwhelmed and our coping strategies don’t work. If the trauma is not processed or if we aren’t able to fight, flee, or in some way manage what is “attacking” us, then we freeze in a way that the unprocessed fear gets locked into our body.
A way some of us deal with the trauma locked in our body is by dissociating – we try to get away from our body, and thus the traumatic situation — but other expressions of trauma are anxiety, depression, sleeplessness, avoidant behaviors, and addiction. These expressions of trauma are almost always enveloped by a sense of shame. Something happens, we get traumatized and we cope the best we can, then hate ourselves for it because it doesn’t look or feel good. It’s the shame that binds the entire process together.
Effects of early trauma are a laundry list: a disrupted sense of self in relation to others, emotional instability, social dysfunction, difficulty recovering from stress, disorganized thinking, a limited window of tolerance, a limited capacity for relationships, poor impulse control, low self-worth, core shame, inability to recognize one’s own needs, a sense of isolation…. Oh, so much! And oh so many of the very reasons we seek out spirituality, even witchcraft; we are searching for healing.
If that search leads a person to the Anderson Faery/Feri lineage of witchcraft before therapeutic work with a qualified therapist has been done to address past trauma the very tools of the tradition could be dangerously retraumatizing. In this lineage we are asked to be present in our bodies, to be fully present for Sex, Self, Passion, Pride and Power. Meditators are now realizing that mindfulness meditation is retraumatizing for the same reason; in mindfulness practice we are asked to be present with the feelings and sensations of the body. If we have unprocessed trauma fear locked in our body, our own breath and body awareness can be jarring, flooding us and popping us right out of the body. We feel the trauma all over again and dissociate. In fact, we will happily watch our body sit and breathe on the cushion – we are well used to dissociating – thinking we are engaged with the practice, when in actuality we are not experiencing embodiment at all.
Retraumatization is a conscious or unconscious reminder of past trauma that results in re-experiencing of the initial trauma itself. It can be triggered by a situation, an attitude or expression, or by certain environments that replicate the dynamics (loss of power/control/safety) of the original trauma. – by Patricia Shelly, MSW, Shelley Hitzel, MSW, and Karen Zgoda, MSW, LCSW, Preventing Retraumatization: A Macro Social Work Approach to Trauma-Informed Practices & Policies
For those of us who dissociate, clearing the mind and entering stillness is a familiar state of numbness. It can be a blissful state, and hard to distinguish from altered states of consciousness. Yet, it is not the mindfulness taught in yoga, and it is not the embodiment required to engage Faery witchcraft safely. Embodiment is the beginning and foundation for more advanced practices in Faery.
Dissociation vs presence?
Meditation instructors and health care professionals who work with trauma survivors are taught to use trauma informed practices which focus on a sense of safety and stabilization (it is not in most of our scope of practice to offer trauma-specific work that focuses on processing trauma). One thing Faery witchcraft is not is safe, and its tools are notoriously destabilizing. Some do survive the crash course of a Faery induced healing crisis, others do not. With so many qualified therapists who specialize in integrating trauma, and so many excellent protocols, like EMDR, there is no reason to risk a student, or risk ourselves.
If you are drawn to Faery, but come from a trauma background, seek out a skilled EMDR therapist first. Give yourself a year of calming the central nervous system and finding safety within your body. You will be grateful you did.
*I am not a professional therapist. My insights come from my own experience and what I have found effective.

Incantation; Francisco Goya
Research on EMDR: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/0057/6d23533c00772adb5ad78b1d44c01b431e51.pdf
To hear Tara Brach speak about meditation and trauma: https://www.tarabrach.com/meditation-and-healing-trauma/
Traci, thank you, this is an excellent unpacking. I have been grappling with these issues in my own healing work, which I think has similar issues at its core – the work with touch tends to retraumatize if you don’t approach it with great care. It’s great to see a faery person talking about this.
This is my from-some-time-ago post about a pretty great trauma book, and about how I’ve been approaching my work for the past couple years.
https://powerinyourhands.wordpress.com/2016/03/24/the-body-keeps-the-score-but-we-knew-that/
Thank you for reading. The research out now about trauma, and how embodied practice can be retraumatizing, is essential knowledge for craft practitioners, especially Faery. Our deeper practices are all based on embodied experience, so this foundation step is crucial. It is also necessary for building whole, integrated human persons. I have van der Kolk’s book. It’s very good.
Do you mind if I reblog?
Frontier of Trauma Treatment
presented by Bessel van der Kolk
https://search.alexanderstreet.com/view/work/bibliographic_entity%7Cvideo_work%7C2542891
In the present study, posterior cingulate, parahippocampal and insular lower GM concentrations have been related to PTSD and responsiveness to EMDR therapy. Furthermore, irrespective of the PTSD diagnosis, trauma load was found to correlate with GM density in the same regions, suggesting a high vulnerability of these structures to the effects of stress and trauma, analogous to the previously known vulnerability in hippocampus, amygdala and prefrontal cortex (McEwan, 2006). These regions are well known to be implicated in processes such as: integration, encoding and retrieval of autobiographical and episodic memories, emotional processing (i.e. classical conditioning, cognitive appraisal, experience of feeling states), interoceptive awareness and self-referential conscious experience. Thus, our study supports lower GM densities in limbic and paralimbic cortices as a potential structural basis for memory and dissociative dysfunction in PTSD. In addition, responsiveness to EMDR psychotherapy, which in part aims to ameliorate such symptomatology, has been preliminarily correlated with the same structural substrates.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022395609002453
This study examined the effectiveness of EMDR therapy for the treatment of adults with PTSD symptoms in Timor Leste. Treatment with EMDR was followed by significant reductions in PTSD, depression, and anxiety symptoms. EMDR desensitization was also followed by significant decreases in the distress and vividness associated with traumatic memories targeted in sessions. These changes were maintained at 3‐month follow‐up.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/jts.22084
[…] and familial beliefs, impressions and world view. Part of that examination may uncover layers of trauma, pain or energetic adhesions. This is where a teacher comes in handy. A teacher can suggest […]
Thank you. Being heartbroken over treatment from a coven we exited in 2017, we were looking for someone who had a good perspective on trauma and witchcraft. 25 years of CBT and 5 of EMDR was ignored by the High Priestess who has been stalking since we left and writing blogs about my life on Patheos Pagan. Ritual.abuse is the history, amongst other things. Now as a practicing Shaman, she is still at it anyway now publicly instead of behind closed doors. This blog renewed faith in witches.
[…] To keep our energy (emotions) healthy and free flowing, we need to experience the fullness of it without stifling it and without being possessed by it. [Note: If you have a trauma background, I recommend you seek therapy first! I’ve written about that here.] […]